Tuesday, 21 May 2013

Review: The Selection by Kiera Cass




Concept

It's post world war 4, and America Singer (Yes, America Singer who happens to be both American and singer, SURPRISE) is living in a semi-dystopian world where caste systems dictate where individuals belong in society (kind of like The Hunger Games with the districts). America (the country) now called Ilea, is ruled by a Monarch (King and Queen) and it’s now time for the Prince, Maxon, to chose a wife through a process called The Selection.

I know what your thinking - Kings, Queens, princes… haven’t we all heard this before?  But this book is strangely addictive, and is a combination of the movie a The Prince and Me and the TV show The Bachelor
 
What we liked:

First off, Keira Cass’s writing was really easy to read and although quite simple kept us engaged throughout the whole book (all of us reading the book in just two sittings). She made the language a breeze to read and kept the book short and sweet.


We all really enjoyed the concept of the book and the world in which it was set. The Caste system really differentiated The Selection from the long list of dystopian books that are currently on shelves.

Next the plot of the book was great – again the whole of idea of the Selection – 18 Girls battling it out to win the Prince Maxon’s heart is going to be interesting no matter what. Keira slipped in little details such as the dresses America and the others wore to the parties and what the Palace looked like. This allowed us to really become invested in the story and we found ourselves rooting for the characters we wanted to win.

Last but no least (and how could forget) Prince Maxon! A highlight of the book, he was cute and sweet and as the book continued... 
 
What we hated:

Although we really enjoyed The Selection there were few things we weren’t really fans of…

The first is Aspen and the (weird) love triangle that was created. We won't give much away but we found Aspen to be insanely annoying and just a waste of space. He couldn’t take a hint and popped up in very unexpected places – not to mention put America in a few very compromising situations!
Also America's world wasn’t explored enough, as we mentioned earlier we loved the world she created and that was just it we wanted to hear more! Keira Cass threw in details about Ilea but never went back to expand on them and just let them as loose ends. At some points we were even left wondering whether they were even worth putting into the book. Possibly the most frustrating element of the book was the cliffhanger ending, which left us unsatisfied and just plain annoyed as there was so many loose ends. 

Finally there were a few awkward and badly written phrases:

"Aspen was dressed in white. He looked angelic." 
(Very creative imagery...)

That was it. I slapped him. "You idiot!" I whisper-yelled at him. "I hate him! I loved you! I wanted you; all I ever wanted was you!" 
(WHAT EVEN IS WHISPER YELLING? IT DEFEATS THE PURPOSE OF WHISPERING!)

"What did stop me was when I heard the gasp that escaped someones mouth as we passed.Maxon and I both turned And there was Aspen I gasped, too"
(REALLY KEIRA WHY SO MANY GASPS)


Read The Selection if you liked:
Hush Hush by Becca Fitzpatrick
The Matched Series by Allie Condie
The Delirium Series by Lauren Oliver
Lola and the French Kiss by Stephanie Perkins

The Bachelor (TV Show)


We give The Selection 3.5 stars out of 5







No comments :

Post a Comment